Blogs

Discover the 10 Best Scar Creams for Surgical Scars

July 18, 2024

When it comes to surgical scars, it can be difficult to find the best products to help them fade. With thousands of scar creams and gels available, finding the perfect one can be overwhelming. While options are always great, too many options can make it hard to understand which ones are quality and which ones won’t have any effect on your scar. 

In order to help you beat the confusion and avoid spending money on useless products, we’ve put together a list of the ten best scar creams for surgical scars.

Key Ingredients

There are some key ingredients to look for when choosing a scar cream for surgical scars. Ingredients like aloe, hyaluronic acid, vitamins E & C, and green tea extract, allantoin, coco oil, retinol, and snail mucinare great ingredients that promote healing. However, there are many other ingredients to look for that we will highlight below.

  1. Scar Protocol - Scar Treatment 

Scar Protocol is at the top of our list because it’s a unique treatment plan that offers different creams for every stage of scar creams. It’s a five-phase treatment that includes different creams and treatments for each stage of healing. It's the best system for scar healing with ingredients such as vitamin E, aloe, allantoin, snail mucin, coco oil, and retinol. You can buy the products individually or sign up for the entire treatment. Each phase has different products to help with the stage of your scar and has treatments for reducing the texture, color correction, and eliminating hard scars. 

  • Scar Reduction: 4.7 out of 5 
  • What We Love: In-depth treatment process that can be bought individually based on your scar stage or all together for new scar healing! Has many incredible healing ingredients. 
  • What We Don’t: Can get pricey for the entire treatment. 

 

  1. Derma-E Scar Cream 

Derma-E Scar Cream is great for small surgical scars that you want to diminish. With ingredients like zinc oxide and allantoin, it can reduce smaller scars while protecting your skin with a built-in SPF. It’s not as in-depth as other treatments, but it’s a quick solution that doesn’t break the bank. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.5 out of 5
  • What We Love: SPF for protection and clean ingredients with a lower price tag.  
  • What We Don’t: Not great for deep, highly visible scars. 

  1. Alastin Regenerating Skin Nectar 

Alastin Regenerating Skin Nectar is a one-step solution to deel surgical scars but is more expensive. However, high-quality silicone, allantoin, and fatty acids are great ways to reduce scar visibility. 

  • Scar Reduction: 4 out of 5
  • What We Love: Great ingredients and proven results. 
  • What We Don’t: High price for a one-step treatment.

  1. Honeydew Blemish Cream 

Honeydew Blemish Cream is an affordable scar cream with natural ingredients that’s safe for sensitive skin. This scar cream is best for lighter scars that need a little hydration. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.2 out of 5 
  • What We Love: Low price point and great for sensitive skin. 
  • What We Don’t: Not as strong of a scar treatment as the others.  

  1. SkinCeuticals Phyto+ 

SkinCeuticals Phyto+ helps with other skin issues as well as scarring. It helps reduce scarring, skin irritation, and discoloration. With ingredients like arbutin glycoside and kojic acid it can work on dark scars. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.9 out of 5
  • What We Love: Multi-use product that helps with more than just scarring! 
  • What We Don’t: Expensive for a small amount of product. 

  1. ScarAway Kelo-cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel

ScarAway Kelo-cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel is best for keloid scars that are difficult to heal. It’s a great solution to deep, raised bumps, but it can take a while before results begin to appear. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.6 out of 5
  • What We Love: Great for keloid scars that are hard to heal. 
  • What We Don’t: Long wait time to see results.  

  1. Bio-Oil Skincare Body Oil 

Bio-Oil Skincare Body Oil is another multi-use product that isn’t strictly marketed as a scar removal cream. Instead, it’s a hydrating and healing body oil that can help with a myriad of different skin issues. Dermatologists love Bio-Oil for its effectiveness at reducing scars and blemishes. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3 out of 5
  • What We Love: Versatile oil great for small scars and blemishes. 
  • What We Don’t: Not as in-depth or good at treating deep scarring and can be messy to use. 

  1. Sunnie Skincare Scar Smooth Elite 

Sunnie Skincare Scar Smooth Elite is a scar healing kit that uses ingredients like allantoin and silicone to heal and fade scars. It is easy to use and has three different tools to help fade scarring. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.8 out of 5 
  • What We Love: Easy and simple to use, and efficient at healing new scars. 
  • What We Don’t: Not as effective at healing older scars. 

  1. ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets

ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets are best for flattening and softening the appearance of scars. They can be worn for ten days at a time and are very successful for scar healing. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.8 out of 5
  • What We Love: Change the texture of scars and softens them. Sheets are almost invisible on the skin! 
  • What We Don’t: Hard to apply and can sometimes react with sensitive skin. Sheets do have to be cut for small scars. 

  1.  Cicatricure Face & Body Scar Gel

Cicatricure Face & Body Scar Gel is great for reducing small scars, stretch marks, and blemish scars. You do have to apply four times a day which can be difficult to manage, and it’s not as effective with deeper scarring. 

  • Scar Reduction: 3.4 out of 5
  • What We Love: Very low price for effective results with smaller scars. 
  • What We Don’t: Can be a hassle to apply four times a day and doesn’t work great with deep scars. 

Conclusion

When looking for the right scar cream, check the ingredients and the description for what kind of scars it treats. Scar Protocol is one of the leading scar  treatments and can help with deep surgical scars, no matter what stage their in. It’s a versatile line of scar cream that uses different ingredients in each phase to ensure the best healing for every surgical scar.